Recently, I talked about the 2007 MOU between the City of New Orleans and the VA, the one that focused in great detail on the current VAMC site between S. Galvez and S. Rocheblave. It was signed on November 19, 2007, and it very clearly envisions a VA site that has already "jumped Galvez" into the neighborhood centered on Outer Banks Bar:
The City was already proffering this "targeted developable and usable area of land" - also known as a dense, recovering, historic neighborhood - to the wolves as of August 2007 per the letter. And it had signed an earlier April 2007 CEA specifying the site.
But all sorts of official documentation in the summer of 2008 kept up the myth that all sorts of alternative sites besides this "RPC" selected site were still being considered.
Here's a letter from VA to the State Historic Preservation Officer in August 2008 sustaining the illusion of three alternative sites:
Did VA ever have any intent of actually selecting one of the alternatives...given the MOU legal agreement with the City that was signed nearly a year earlier?
A letter from VA to SHPO in November 2008 further sustained the mirage:
....the key language being...
For more on this series of events, see this classic Gambit piece from December 2008. It's important to keep a clear timeline in mind.
Showing posts with label MOUA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MOUA. Show all posts
Wednesday, August 24, 2011
Tuesday, August 23, 2011
"We're gettin what they promised. They said we'd be last. And we are last."
At the most recent VA neighborhood meeting, I noted that the ongoing work on streets like S. Rocheblave, Palmyra, and Cleveland - the streets immediate above the VA Footprint - is being done explicitly in furtherance of the VAMC project. Some seemed to take umbrage at that assertion, but I think it's relevant given the problems the street work has been causing for residents for months and the constant attempts to shift blame.
The title quote comes from Mr. Leon, a resident on S. Rocheblave, who has been facing tumult on his street, the lakeside boundary of the VA site, since the fall of 2010 - dust, digging, mud, vibration, sudden lack of access, etc. He's been at almost every VA neighborhood meeting since they began early last fall to discuss the issue. And, as he noted, it's still not over.
A look at a 2007 letter from the City of New Orleans to the VA Administration, incorporated as Attachment B in the 2007 Memorandum of Understanding between the City and VA, shows that the street work is very explicitly being conducted in furtherance of the VA project:
The text reveals that the VA, even if it is not conducting the street improvement work on the adjacent and feeder streets, was very much involved in the planning of what the reasonable improvements would consist of...
....which, one would think, would entail some planning to ensure that the work was conducted in a manner that reduced impact on the peripheral neighbors.
At any rate, the VA's construction contractor has at least made greater outreach efforts to address existing and potential damage to homes than the City of New Orleans has - or the City's contractors.
On a different note, the meeting also revealed that VA had consulted with the State Historic Preservation Office regarding Dixie Brewery to see how much of the building can be saved, the 1907 portion being the part VA wants to save. A VA rep said that VA was seeking ways to stabilize some of the weaker external wall bays from the inside.
The title quote comes from Mr. Leon, a resident on S. Rocheblave, who has been facing tumult on his street, the lakeside boundary of the VA site, since the fall of 2010 - dust, digging, mud, vibration, sudden lack of access, etc. He's been at almost every VA neighborhood meeting since they began early last fall to discuss the issue. And, as he noted, it's still not over.
A look at a 2007 letter from the City of New Orleans to the VA Administration, incorporated as Attachment B in the 2007 Memorandum of Understanding between the City and VA, shows that the street work is very explicitly being conducted in furtherance of the VA project:
The text reveals that the VA, even if it is not conducting the street improvement work on the adjacent and feeder streets, was very much involved in the planning of what the reasonable improvements would consist of...
....which, one would think, would entail some planning to ensure that the work was conducted in a manner that reduced impact on the peripheral neighbors.
At any rate, the VA's construction contractor has at least made greater outreach efforts to address existing and potential damage to homes than the City of New Orleans has - or the City's contractors.
On a different note, the meeting also revealed that VA had consulted with the State Historic Preservation Office regarding Dixie Brewery to see how much of the building can be saved, the 1907 portion being the part VA wants to save. A VA rep said that VA was seeking ways to stabilize some of the weaker external wall bays from the inside.
Tuesday, July 19, 2011
Update on Dixie Brewery - and ongoing concerns about "replacement acreage"
According to VA representatives at the VA Neighborhood Meeting this evening, the structural assessment for Dixie Brewery is complete. It is now in the hands of the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO).
SHPO has requested a consultation, and the VA is working to set up that consultation, which will focus on the entire building, in the next three weeks. I asked if this was an official consultation under Section 106 (federal law) or just a meeting. I was told it was an official consultation. When asked, VA said that consulting parties under Section 106 were not invited to the consultation.
When pressed, VA would not even give an estimated date for when it would release the assessment to the public (I encourage any Louisiana residents out there to make a public records request upon the Louisiana SHPO to try to obtain the document).
One VA representative on hand did say, when addressing some query, that "...the building did take a lot of water."
And that somewhat ominous note brings up another issue, one that was also addressed this evening: what if Dixie is found to be inadequate for the VA's research facility needs, for whatever reason?
Well, according to the old Memorandum of Understanding that governs (or at least governed) the relationship between the City of New Orleans and the VA for the project (a Nagin-era folly), the VA could look for "replacement acreage." In other words, if Dixie doesn't work...then the City of New Orleans will provide the VA with replacement land. Now that's ominous - especially for the many people who still live between S. Rocheblave and Broad Street, immediately adjacent to the present VA Footprint.
Here's the provision, something I'd call "The Sinister Clause" - and VA, when asked, would not take the option off the table (although since VA has seemingly had the Dixie Brewery property tansferred to itself, from what I know...it's unclear whether that would moot the issue):
Note that the replacement acreage under the agreement would be contiguous to the existing VA Footprint - or within 150 feet.
Someone could also make a public records request upon the City to determine if it has received notice in writing from VA regarding VA's intentions for the Dixie Parcel - or to see if there has been any discussion of replacement acreage that would functionally grow the size of the VA Footprint as we know it, almost certainly resulting in the destruction of something else around the current site.
SHPO has requested a consultation, and the VA is working to set up that consultation, which will focus on the entire building, in the next three weeks. I asked if this was an official consultation under Section 106 (federal law) or just a meeting. I was told it was an official consultation. When asked, VA said that consulting parties under Section 106 were not invited to the consultation.
When pressed, VA would not even give an estimated date for when it would release the assessment to the public (I encourage any Louisiana residents out there to make a public records request upon the Louisiana SHPO to try to obtain the document).
One VA representative on hand did say, when addressing some query, that "...the building did take a lot of water."
And that somewhat ominous note brings up another issue, one that was also addressed this evening: what if Dixie is found to be inadequate for the VA's research facility needs, for whatever reason?
Well, according to the old Memorandum of Understanding that governs (or at least governed) the relationship between the City of New Orleans and the VA for the project (a Nagin-era folly), the VA could look for "replacement acreage." In other words, if Dixie doesn't work...then the City of New Orleans will provide the VA with replacement land. Now that's ominous - especially for the many people who still live between S. Rocheblave and Broad Street, immediately adjacent to the present VA Footprint.
Here's the provision, something I'd call "The Sinister Clause" - and VA, when asked, would not take the option off the table (although since VA has seemingly had the Dixie Brewery property tansferred to itself, from what I know...it's unclear whether that would moot the issue):
Note that the replacement acreage under the agreement would be contiguous to the existing VA Footprint - or within 150 feet.
Someone could also make a public records request upon the City to determine if it has received notice in writing from VA regarding VA's intentions for the Dixie Parcel - or to see if there has been any discussion of replacement acreage that would functionally grow the size of the VA Footprint as we know it, almost certainly resulting in the destruction of something else around the current site.
Monday, November 2, 2009
VA Footprint Update
The VA has agreed to give the City of New Orleans an extension on clearing the VA footprint - the site need not be construction-ready until July of 2010.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)